Amazon’s Alteration to Echo’s Privacy Settings Sparks Controversy
An email was recently dispatched by Amazon to specific Echo users, alerting them to the necessity of granting consent for their Alexa voice recordings to be directed to the company’s cloud for processing. This communication was directed towards users who had the Do Not Send Voice Recordings feature activated on their Echo device, ensuring that their commands were processed locally; nonetheless, as of March 28, this feature will no longer be accessible, as all recordings will be processed at Amazon data centers, as verified by TechRepublic.
When the specified date arrives, any Echo device still set up with this feature enabled will automatically transition to Don’t Save Recordings mode, resulting in voice commands being relayed to Amazon’s cloud for processing and subsequently erased. Previously stored voice recordings will also be wiped clean, and Alexa’s voice ID—used for recognizing individual users’ voices to tailor responses—will be deactivated.
The rationale provided by Amazon in the email for discontinuing the Do Not Send Voice Recordings feature was to “enhance Alexa’s functionality with generative AI attributes that rely on Amazon’s secure cloud’s computational power.” This suggests that Amazon aims to accumulate more voice data to refine AI training and advance its intelligent speaker technology.
GenAI and the pursuit of increased voice data
Amazon was contacted by TechRepublic for verification, and a representative issued a standard statement affirming that the company is “concentrating on the privacy tools and controls most utilized by consumers, which synergize effectively with generative AI interactions.”
EXPLORE: US Announces Cyber Trust Mark for Identifying Secure Smart Devices
This development surfaced shortly after the introduction of Alexa+, an AI-enabled variant of Amazon’s virtual assistant. Scheduled for release this month, Alexa+ will assimilate information from a user’s home cameras, emails, personal schedules, and more to offer astute responses.
The Amazon Devices division, specializing in Alexa-enabled hardware, has reportedly incurred losses totaling $25 billion from 2017 to 2021, as per findings by The Wall Street Journal. Navigating competition from Apple’s Siri, Google’s Gemini, and ChatGPT’s voice capabilities could be pivotal for Amazon’s longevity in the smart assistant sector.
Amazon’s tumultuous past involving privacy issues
The email dispatched to Echo users emphasized that voice records will be encrypted during transmission and that the Amazon cloud incorporates “multiple layers of security safeguards to ensure the protection of consumer data.” Given Amazon’s history with voice command privacy, some users might harbor apprehensions regarding the updated settings.
In 2023, Amazon opted to pay $25 million in civil penalties due to extended retention of children’s Alexa recordings, violating child privacy regulations. That same year, Amazon’s Ring faced a $5.8 million fine after revelations that employees and contractors had unrestricted access to customers’ private video footage.
Amazon faced criticism for discreetly storing Alexa recordings as default until a U.S. Senator publicly interrogated Jeff Bezos about the practice—five years post the inaugural Echo release.
Prior to the adjustment, the Do Not Send Voice Recordings configuration was exclusive to U.S.-based users with an Echo Dot (4th Gen), Echo Show 10, or Echo Show 15 configured in English. Despite impacting a limited user base, individuals who prioritize security and solely engage in elementary offline tasks with their devices may interpret this as a compromise on privacy post their acquisition of a product perceived to align with their security requirements.
About Author
