Explosion or Collapse? Understanding Conflicting Signals on the Tech Employment Arena
Are we witnessing a golden era or a dark abyss for individuals seeking opportunities in the technology and cybersecurity sectors?
The response varies according to the source consulted and/or the type of media coverage one follows.
Let’s first analyze the headlines and narratives from the initial part of 2024:
Geekwire.com — Tech market dynamics in continuous flux with persistent layoffs and challenges for seasoned professionals to secure employment:
“Following her layoff in September, Jenny Richards anticipated a swift job transition. With prior roles in product management at various Seattle tech firms such as Expedia, Tableau, Microsoft, and Accenture, as well as experience with a startup focusing on recruitment software development, she was well-versed in the nuances of tech recruitment.
“However, after numerous applications, some with internal recommendations, none came to fruition. She found herself teetering on the edge of losing unemployment benefits. Eventually, she reached the final stages of an interview process only to be left hanging, without any clarification.
“’Securing a job was a challenge,’ lamented Richards. ‘Nobody responded to my calls. It felt futile.’”
CNN — The employment landscape for college graduates emits caution signals for the US labor market:
“Receiving job rejection emails has almost become comical for Bryn Savidge at this juncture.
“’It’s as if they all follow a standardized AI template to craft rejection messages,’ expressed Savidge, who completed studies at Kenyon College near Columbus, Ohio, majoring in environmental science. A recurring feedback is ‘We recognize your aspirations for global impact, yet we opted for candidates with superior qualifications,’ she noted. ‘They maintain a thematic environmental commentary.'”
Techopedia — Envisioning the Conclusion of Tech Workforce Reductions in 2024:
- “Tech corporations persist in workforce downsizing: Corporations such as Tesla, Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, Apple, Cisco, SAP, and Sony have executed substantial cutbacks.
- Over the initial quarter of 2024, beyond 270 tech enterprises within the sector laid off more than 70,000 employees, as substantiated by the layoffs tracker.
- The layoffs mirror a prevalent trend within the tech labor market, where firms increasingly pivot towards AI and automation for throughput and innovation, leading to a diminished human workforce.
- Rampant tech dismissals have initiated the emergence of ‘Layoff Diaries,’ a burgeoning phenomenon where employees document and share their layoff encounters online.”
Federal News Network — By one estimate, the cybersecurity job sector is facing scarcity:
“Tom Temin – There’s a prevalent belief that a million cybersecurity roles remain vacant across the nation, yet your analysis identifies around 330,000 or so listings. Could it be conceivable that the remaining two-thirds of a million posts have been engaged, signaling an amelioration in the scenario?
“Deidre Diamond – That’s one viewpoint. I wish it were valid. The widespread notion that over a million cybersecurity positions lie unfilled is somewhat fanciful. There’s a data element encompassing uncertainty. From our vantage point, what’s apparent is the dwindling promotion of cybersecurity roles by corporate entities, state and municipal administrations, and government contractors alike. This dataset encompasses scrutiny of 30 principal job platforms in addition to Fortune 500 companies’ websites. I’m skeptical that the landscape is improving. I’ve accrued a decade in this domain. The escalating threat of burnout has been a longstanding menace. With the prevailing economic shift, driving capitalism to curtail the necessity for cybersecurity professionals within enterprises, burnout concerns intensify by the day.”
CNBC — ‘NEETS’ and ‘new unemployables’ — delineating the reluctance of some young adults to enter the job market:
“Despite the unemployment rate maintaining a record low at or below 4%, a sizeable segment of job-seekers remains unplaced. Furthermore, not everyone aspires to secure employment.
“A fraction, labeled ‘NEETs’ denoting individuals not involved in employment, training, or education, opt-out of the workforce largely due to discouragement rooted in their economic circumstances.
“Conversely, another group comprises well-qualified yet youthfully exuberant candidates grappling with obtaining roles, representing a category termed “new unemployables,” as per a recent study by Korn Ferry.”
HOLD ON A MOMENT …
Before plunging into despondency, delve into these job market narratives conveying a contrasting tale:
Washington Post — Escalating demand for robust cybersecurity propelling an upsurge in job opportunities:
“Cyber-attacks have nearly doubled over the last half-decade — averaging 758,000 annually — per reports from the FBI’s Internet Criminal Complaint Center (IC3). These figures represent documented cases. After dismantling the Hive ransomware network in 2023, the FBI unveiled that only one in five victims had reported incidents to authorities. The escalating threat has fueled substantial growth in the cybersecurity sector. The Department of Labor anticipates sustained expansion, while findings released by Cybersecurity Ventures indicate a tripling of unfilled positions worldwide since 2013. While the pace has plateaued, and the US tech industry shed roles last year, numerous vacancies persist within the country.
“The demand has been particularly pronounced in the nation’s capital as governmental bodies and private enterprises vie for skilled personnel.”
“The query no longer revolves around working remotely or not. Specialists argue that the focus now lies on recruiting talent without geographical boundaries for tech positions.
“’Remote work acts as an introduction to borderless operation,’ remarked Jeremy Johnson, CEO of AI-equipped tech talent platform Andela, catering to clients like Goldman Sachs, Github, and Coursera. ‘Once you realize that physical presence in an office all five days a week is not a necessity to build an engaging culture, foster connectivity to the mission, and tackle intricate challenges, you begin to acknowledge the presence of exceptional individuals across the globe.’”
CSPAN — Insights from Emily Peck on the U.S. Employment Scenario and Economic Landscape
DECRYPTING THE CONFUSING COMMUNICATION
My current analysis indicates a contrasting scenario prevailing countrywide with respect to tech and cyber roles.
On one hand, the demand for AI proficiency is skyrocketing, prompting numerous individuals to upgrade skills, enroll in courses, and tweak their resumes to encompass GenAI and AI competencies. Additionally, there is a sustained necessity for specific cybersecurity proficiencies, particularly in high-demand regions like Washington, D.C., boasting a significant federal workforce and contractors supporting defense and intelligence sectors.
Nevertheless, concurrently, I have been receiving feedback from numerous adept cyber and tech professionals across diverse domains, from developers to data specialists, facing challenges in securing roles they perceive as long-term career options nationwide. Although these professionals are securing short-term positions and project assignments, many are encountering difficulties in identifying a fitting career pathway in tech positions.
Several tech firms are evidently exercising discernment in their recruitment processes, some even imposing recruitment freezes, despite witnessing a surge in stock market valuation. Conversely, a parallel level of caution is not discernible in the domain of state and local tech and cyber employments.
I am recommending some acquaintances to contemplate pursuing governmental roles, and I am aware of professionals and leaders contemplating a shift to the public sector despite substantial remuneration (and stock option) differentials.
Prior to delving deeper, I would like to guide you through some resources previously provided on this subject by Lohrmann on Cybersecurity. In the past, I outlined details on navigating a career in cybersecurity, and I also elucidated on how the government can reap benefits and attract skilled resources post corporate tech layoffs in the current scenario.
PARTING THOUGHTS
We currently find ourselves at an intriguing juncture, with some voices asserting a deceleration in the U.S. economy, while others emphasize the continued prosperity of the tech job domain.
Assessing the impact of factors such as the expanding remote workforce and COVID-19-influenced hiring on the prevailing job market proves challenging.
Are we currently witnessing staffing level adjustments post a phase of excessive recruitment in recent years? Many indications suggest the affirmative. Evidently, we are observing a deceleration in technology and risk management roles within the private sector.
Only time will reveal whether the ongoing sluggishness in tech and cyber staffing patterns is momentary or marks the inception of a more pronounced shift in the job market amidst the nascent “era of AI.”
About Author
